New York Decriminalized IV Drug Needles - What’s About to Come

Introduction:  This week, New York decriminalized the possession and sale of needles (used for intravenous drug use). Like all reform and harm reduction models, it purports to be some enlightened policy – refraining from criminalizing a disease. 

Analysis:  There a multitude of flawed presumptions all shrouded in either a complete misunderstanding of how the drug trade operates or a zealous adherence to some utopian ideal.  But let’s just talk about the dealer side.  Here are some simple truisms:

1.       All drug users are supplied by drug dealers (save those who engage in prescription fraud or manufacture their own). 

2.       Drug use by the destitute addict is funded by crime committed upon society.

3.       Drug dealers want more drug use – the more prevalent and ease with which individuals can use, the greater the demand for their product.

4.       With all of that in mind, the losers of this policy are the good citizens of New York and the addicts themselves.  Relaxed drug laws lead to increased use – more addicts.  That is why the American Society of Addictive Medicine wrote a white paper criticizing the legalization of marijuana.  As ASAM notes, once society allows conduct, the perceived threat goes down, and use goes up.  Remember, in the last several years, North America has been bombarded with groups promoting the legalization of marijuana – as a result, there are ten times the number of daily marijuana users than when Bill Clinton was president.  The trajectory of increased drug use is astounding … and alarming.

5.       Like most reform movements, the purported benefactors of the compassionate program are in reality its greatest victims.

6.       In contrast, the greatest benefactor of this policy are the drug dealers.  For thousands of years, conduct is either allowed by society or prohibited. 

Conclusion:  Over 250 years ago, Jean-Jacques Rosseau wrote The Social Contract.  In this classic work, he wrote, “Frequent pardons signalize that crimes will soon need no pardon; and anyone can see what that must lead to.”  What Rosseau claimed was clear to anyone, is not clear at all to many today. 

Brian Surber

Brian is a bestselling author, national speaker, trainer, and career law enforcement professional.  Brian is currently the first assistant district attorney for the Twelfth Judicial District for Rogers, Mayes, and Craig Counties. Surber was formerly a special agent with the Oklahoma Bureau of Narcotics.

https://www.briansurber.com
Previous
Previous

The Supreme Court’s Important Decisions on Qualified Immunity

Next
Next

Marijuana and Pain Treatment - The Fallacy of an Alternative to Opioids